Big question: Should Commune go Open Source?


Usually, I use this newsletter to share what I’m reading or thinking. Today, I’m flipping the script. I need your brain on one specific thing I’m wrestling with.

Should we make Commune fully open-source?

I’ve been building Commune as a headless, creator-first alternative to Substack. The goal is total independence. But lately, I’ve been asking myself if we need to take that a step further.

You know my track record here. I built the AsyncAPI Initiative on the premise that specifications should belong to the community, not a single corporation. I literally turned down a million-dollar offer to acquire AsyncAPI because I knew it had to remain neutral.

I don’t compromise on digital liberty.

So, the question is: Should we do the same for Commune? Should we build the alternative that guarantees you’re never locked in and never beholden to a platform’s algorithm or roadmap?

I need to know what you think.

Hit the button below and let me know what you think.

Av. Joaquín Costa, 16, Badajoz, Badajoz 06001
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Fran Méndez

Hey hey! I'm Fran, the creator of the AsyncAPI specification (the industry standard for defining asynchronous APIs). Subscribe to my newsletter —The Weekly Shift— where I share expert advice about building Event-Driven Architecture and share my journey writing my first book, Shift: The Playbook for Event-Driven Architecture Advocacy.

Read more from Fran Méndez

I’ve been thinking a lot about what Commune should look like. Chatting with Steven Willmott, he suggested something I never thought about: is Commune really a Substack alternative? I mean, Commune doesn’t send the emails. It’s not a competitor to Kit, Mailchimp, Beehiiv, Ghost, and other ESPs. Instead, it integrates all these networks. Substack is a closed network. That’s a fact. And it’s a fair business model, this is not meant to be a critique. Kit, Mailchimp, Beehiiv, Ghost, Buttondown,...

Focus!

This week I have been super focused on strategy for Commune. For a while, I thought having a flagship community on the platform to use as a rock-solid case study would be a really great idea. I played around with creating a paid community and newsletter to help people become unrejectable. It would be a space with periodic webinars from different folks teaching you how to improve your skills, share your work, and make jobs find you instead of the other way around. Building this would also give...

The following is an article by Iván García Sainz-Aja, , in response to a previous essay I wrote. When I sent it, Iván quickly replied shocked by my words. He couldn't believe I was saying: ...right now, people are too focused on the “easy” wins of generation because building the runtime integration, like a rock-solid Spring plugin, is hard work. This is what he has been working on for years! And the worst part is that I was aware of it but, for someone reason, it didn't come to my mind when...