Two sentences that shut down any VC conversation


I recently got a couple of VCs interested in investing in Commune.

Whenever this happens, I always ask why they want to invest and what they are asking in exchange. It's always the same. They want a huge part of the cake. Usually, they want more than half at this stage. And they offer some good money. It's good for me, but it's actually not much for them. I'm talking about tickets from 200k to 500k USD.

However, what many people never tell you is that VCs strictly want hockey stick growth. They don't want to help you build a sustainable business. They want exponential growth. If you won't make it happen, they'll close your company. Actually, it becomes their company because you sold it in exchange for some investment.

That's fair, and it's a good trade if that's exactly what you want. However, it's incredibly risky at this stage to take that money because I only have the promise that it may work. I still have to validate Commune actually works.

I've been there. I've seen a great startup fail because their investors forced the founders to change their strategy in the middle of the course. That change damaged the company completely. What could have been a really sustainable business for those founders and perhaps one or two more employees ended up closing for good.

I don't want that for Commune. I want Commune to be sustainable, so I won't take VC money this early. Sure, I'm not new to this, and I know that at some point I may have to accept it as the only way to go. But I'll only do that once the business is fully validated. At that stage, you are playing a completely different game. You don't have to give up 50 percent of the company.

Taking VC money can make a great impact on your company, but it can also ruin it quickly.

In both of my conversations with VCs in the last month, I honestly told them I don't want Commune to become a huge corporation. I also told them I don't want to be a millionaire. I just want to have enough money to have a great life — and I'm cheap!

If you ever want to shut down a conversation with a VC, these two sentences are pure gold 😄

I'll keep bootstrapping Commune and we'll see where it takes us. Perhaps I fail to make it work, it just stays small and sustainable, or maybe it becomes so big that I have to accept I can't do this as a bootstrapped business anymore.

So this is my question for you this week: when do you think it actually makes sense to trade control of your company for a pile of venture capital? Hit the button below and let's chat on Commune.

Av. Joaquín Costa, 16, Badajoz, Badajoz 06001
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Fran Méndez

Hey hey! I'm Fran, the creator of the AsyncAPI specification (the industry standard for defining asynchronous APIs). Subscribe to my newsletter —The Weekly Shift— where I share expert advice about building Event-Driven Architecture and share my journey writing my first book, Shift: The Playbook for Event-Driven Architecture Advocacy.

Read more from Fran Méndez
Collin Wynter delivering an unintended masterclass on leadership at the Sasquatch Music Festival in 2009

You have probably seen the video of Collin Wynter at the Sasquatch Music Festival back in 2009. If you somehow missed it, you absolutely need to watch it right now. It is a complete masterclass in how to build a movement. The video shows Collin dancing entirely alone on a grassy hill. He gives it everything he has, just throwing his arms around and stomping his feet while hundreds of people sit on the grass around him. For a few solid minutes, he is entirely isolated. Most people would get...

I’ve been thinking a lot about what Commune should look like. Chatting with Steven Willmott, he suggested something I never thought about: is Commune really a Substack alternative? I mean, Commune doesn’t send the emails. It’s not a competitor to Kit, Mailchimp, Beehiiv, Ghost, and other ESPs. Instead, it integrates all these networks. Substack is a closed network. That’s a fact. And it’s a fair business model, this is not meant to be a critique. Kit, Mailchimp, Beehiiv, Ghost, Buttondown,...

Focus!

This week I have been super focused on strategy for Commune. For a while, I thought having a flagship community on the platform to use as a rock-solid case study would be a really great idea. I played around with creating a paid community and newsletter to help people become unrejectable. It would be a space with periodic webinars from different folks teaching you how to improve your skills, share your work, and make jobs find you instead of the other way around. Building this would also give...